Keuka Lake, Fishing: Seasons, Records, and Outdoor Adventure
Fishermen exploring Keuka Lake can target a variety of species, making it a favored destination for those seeking a mixed fishing experience in New York State. Atlantic salmon, rainbow trout, brown trout, lake trout, northern pike, chain pickerel, walleye, pumpkinseed, black crappie, bluegill, rock bass, smallmouth bass, largemouth bass, and yellow perch are all found in Keuka Lake.
Keuka Lake, between Yates and Steuben Counties with charming towns like Penn Yan, Branchport, and Hammondsport dotting its shores, is the third largest finger lake known for fishing in New York State. Spanning 19.6 miles with a maximum width of 1.9 miles and reaching a depth of 183 feet, this body of water provides an expansive and diverse fishing landscape.
Connected to the intricate water network of the region, Keuka Lake contributes to the ecological richness of its surroundings. Keuka Lake is historically known for its lake trout and smallmouth bass fishing.
In recent times, the Keuka Lake fishing has gained renown for lake trout, commonly referred to as “lakers,” sustained entirely through natural reproduction. Additionally, the introduction of rainbow trout around the turn of the century has resulted in a self-sustaining population.
More of NY’s best fishing spots
Seasonal Fishing Techniques by Species
Spring (March to May)
During the spring months on Keuka Lake, fishing activity experiences a notable upswing. Anglers focus on lake trout, with late winter to early spring providing optimal conditions for fly fishing and jigging, seeing wooly buggers and scented lures such as the Berkley Gulp performing well.
The warming waters prompt increased activity among smallmouth and largemouth bass, making this season opportune for those in pursuit of trophy-sized catches. The lake’s distinctive topography, characterized by points and bluffs, contributes to a unique fishing experience.
Summer (June to August)
Summer on Keuka Lake is the pinnacle of bass fishing, drawing avid anglers eager to pursue smallmouth and largemouth bass and secure trophy-sized specimens. This season unfolds with a focus on the diverse opportunities that extend beyond bass fishing.
While smallmouth and largemouth bass remain the primary targets, anglers also engage in lake trout jigging. Additionally, the pursuit of chain pickerel becomes a viable option during the summer months, with angler usually landing them on minnows suspended under bobbers, or free floating under a bare hook.
Though northern pike are generally viewed as bonus catches, certain areas of Keuka Lake, particularly those in close proximity to the reeds along the lake edge, offer thrilling opportunities for encounters with these predatory fish. Anglers frequently achieve success by employing a deliberate slow retrieval technique, whether using bait or a fly, it’s important to use wire trace when targeting northern pike due to their ferocious set of teeth.
Fall (September to November)
In the autumn months on Keuka Lake, northern pike fishing becomes more prominent. Simultaneously, improvements in largemouth bass fishing become apparent, adding to the allure of fall angling. This season proves particularly favorable for lake trout enthusiasts, as these formidable fish alter their feeding habits, focusing on freshwater shrimp and perch fry.
Adding to the diversity of potential catches, anglers can strategically target walleye during this period. Walleye, known for their preference for low-light conditions, make dawn and dusk prime times for successful angling.
A productive approach involves trolling along the lake’s structure, which includes drop-offs, points, and submerged rock formations. This method capitalizes on the walleye’s behavior and increases the chances of a rewarding catch during the fall season on Keuka Lake.
Winter (December to February)
Keuka Lake transforms into a winter wonderland for ice-fishing enthusiasts during the colder months. Anglers primarily target lake trout by identifying deeper waters and utilizing specialized ice fishing techniques such as jigging with flutter spoons and setting up tip-ups with live bait.
Despite the logistical challenges presented by winter conditions, Keuka Lake remains a reliable destination for winter anglers seeking the thrill of catching lake trout in the late fall and early winter months.
Tip-ups are a popular method during winter on Keuka Lake. Anglers position these devices over strategically chosen spots, baited with live or dead baitfish. When a lake trout takes the bait, the tip-up signals the strike, allowing anglers to quickly respond and secure their catch. Pairing tip ups with an underwater camera or fish finder can be a formidable combination when fishing Keuka at winter.
What Keuka Lake is Known For
At Keuka Lake, an extraordinary catch stands out—the capture of a brown trout weighing an impressive 22 pounds and 4 ounces in 1979. This monumental achievement, though attributed to an anonymous angler, held a prominent record until recently surpassed by an even more substantial catch in one of the larger Finger Lakes. The evolving records highlight the competitive nature of New York fishing, with each catch representing a pursuit of extraordinary angling feats.
Beyond fishing, Keuka Lake offers a wide range of of activities. The Keuka Lake Outlet Trail beckons outdoor lovers, providing a well-maintained path for hiking, cycling, and even winter sports. The trail unveils stunning views, including the Seneca and Cascade Mills Falls.
Charming towns like Penn Yan and Hammondsport, each with its own unique character, offer delightful opportunities for tourists to explore. Their Main Streets, lined with historic storefronts, cozy diners, and inviting coffee shops, create a nostalgic small-town atmosphere. Just outside Penn Yan, the Windmill Farm & Craft Market adds to the appeal, making for a perfect day trip filled with local flavor and artisan finds.
Hammondsport, at the southern tip of Keuka Lake, is a key hub in Finger Lakes wine production, known for its vineyards and wineries. Nearby, the Finger Lakes Boating Museum showcases the region’s maritime history with a collection of handcrafted wooden boats.
Wineries like Pleasant Valley Wine and Dr. Konstantin Frank Wine Cellars attract visitors with their heritage and high-quality wines. Local breweries, including Steuben Brewery and Keg & Barrel Brewing, offer a wide range of craft beers. Keuka Lake also supports outdoor recreation, from kayaking and canoeing to boat rentals.
Keuka Lake State Park provides space for swimming, camping, and scenic picnics. The park’s dog-friendly trails offer a leisurely stroll, while the sandy beach provides a perfect spot for families to enjoy the water. Keuka Lake, with its diverse offerings, emerges not only as a superb location for fishing enthusiasts but as a multifaceted destination, inviting exploration of its rich history, outdoor wonders, and culinary delights.
Boat Ramps, Boat Launches, Marinas, and Public Access Points
Keuka Lake offers several well-equipped access points for boaters, particularly near Branchport and Penn Yan.
Keuka Lake State Park, just east of Branchport off Route 54A, provides public access with concrete ramps, a pumpout station, and parking for up to 50 cars with trailers. Operated by the Office of Parks, Recreation, and Historic Preservation, the site charges a user fee and remains open for winter launching, weather permitting.
In Penn Yan, a major boating hub off Route 14A, boaters can use multiple hard-surface ramps and docks, with parking for up to 120 vehicles with trailers. A launch fee applies. This village-operated site offers easy access and convenient amenities for both residents and visitors.
Indian Pines Park, located off Route 54A on Old Pines Trail Road, is dedicated to ice fishing but does not have boat launching facilities. Meanwhile, Guyanoga Creek Site, at the Route 54A bridge in Branchport, features a gravel ramp for small trailered or cartop boats. Managed by the DEC, it includes parking for four vehicles with trailers and sits about 250 yards north of the lake.
All sites are accessible via Route 54A, which links Branchport and Penn Yan. Boaters can find detailed directions and updates through the Boat Launch Sites for Yates County webpage.
Whether looking for full-service ramps, quiet winter access, or sites for smaller craft, Keuka Lake provides a range of launch options across Yates County.
