Schoharie Creek & Schoharie Creek Reservoir Fishing Species and Tips

Fishermen visiting Schoharie Creek can target a variety of fish species, including walleye, northern pike, fallfish, carp, brown trout, rainbow trout, bass, and walleye. The creek’s waters provide opportunities for both novice and experienced anglers, making it a versatile destination for those seeking a range of fishing experiences. 

Schoharie Creek, a prominent river in New York’s Schoharie County, meanders northward for 93 miles from the base of Indian Head Mountain in the Catskills through the picturesque Schoharie Valley, ultimately joining the Mohawk River. Along its path, the Schoharie Creek Reservoir near Mine Kill State Park provides open water fishing opportunities. The Schoharie Valley is rich in history, with the creek playing a role in significant events such as the Cobleskill Massacre during the American Revolutionary War. 

Schoharie Creek is intersected by the Erie Canal, showcasing the engineering marvels of the past. The presence of such historic sites adds cultural richness to the fishing experience, allowing anglers to appreciate the creek’s role in shaping the region’s transportation history.

More prime fishing spots in NY

Seasonal Fishing Techniques

Spring (March to May)

In the spring months of March to May, fishing in Schoharie Creek focuses on brown trout and rainbow trout. This period offers excellent opportunities for fly fishing, capitalizing on the fly  hatches such as Blue Winged Olives, Blue Quills, Mahogany Duns, Light Cahills, and American March browns. 

Given the creek’s topography with numerous boulders, success can be achieved by concentrating on deeper pockets near trees or grassy banks where the trout find their food. If conventional dead drift tactics prove ineffective, fishermen can switch to a technique involving lifting the fly off the surface and quickly dropping it back down for increased chances of success.

As an alternative to trout fishing, anglers can also fish for panfish in various sections of Schoharie Creek during the spring months, adding diversity and excitement to their fishing experience. Panfish can provide an enjoyable fishing action, contributing to a well-rounded angling experience in this waterbody.

Summer (June to July)

Summer presents more challenging conditions for trout fishing in Schoharie Creek, as the water temperatures may rise beyond the optimal range for these species. During this season, anglers are advised to shift their focus to the creek’s smaller tributaries, which can provide suitable conditions for fishing when the main creek becomes too warm. 

Checking the stream flow and current conditions through resources like the USGS stream gauge near Lexington, NY is crucial for ensuring an informed and optimal fishing experience. Overall, understanding the distinct characteristics of each season is essential for anglers to tailor their techniques and target species accordingly in Schoharie Creek.

Fall (August to November)

Brown trout, in particular, become more active during the fall as they spawn and travel from the reservoir into the creek. The increased activity and movement of the trout create favorable conditions for successful fishing. 

Moreover, the fall season introduces a shift in insect hatches, with terrestrials becoming more significant. Anglers should take advantage of this season’s offerings. Brown trout fishing and adapting their techniques to capitalize on the changing dynamics of the water.

Winter (December to February)

As winter sets in, the fishing environment undergoes significant changes. While the water may become colder and potentially less hospitable for certain fish species like trout, the Schoharie Reservoir offers alternative opportunities. 

Fishermen can shift their focus towards ice fishing on the Schoharie Creek Reservoir. Targeting species like walleye, which are prevalent and popular in the area, becomes a rewarding pursuit during the winter months.

A flasher or sonar unit is invaluable for ice fishing. It helps you identify the depth of the water, locate fish, and observe their behavior. This is particularly helpful when targeting walleye, as they often suspend at varying depths.

Ice fishing techniques, such as using tip-ups or jigging, can be employed to target walleye. Additionally, anglers should exercise caution and ensure the ice is safe before engaging in winter fishing activities. 

What Schoharie Creek is Known For

Schoharie Creek, known for its  fishing, holds a remarkable angling record that highlights the passion and dedication of its local anglers.

On October 11, 2016, David Bilby, a 57-year-old resident of Richmondville, N.Y., achieved an extraordinary milestone by catching and releasing his 26,482nd bass on Schoharie Creek. 

The record showcases not only the abundance of smallmouth bass in the creek but also the commitment of local anglers like Bilby.  

However, the creek’s history is dark and tragic. During the American Revolutionary War when a massacre occurred in the valley of Cobleskill Creek, a tributary of Schoharie, as Iroquois Native Americans attacked a settlement of colonists in 1778. The creek, spanning 93 miles, has also been marked by bridge collapses, including incidents in 1987 and 2011, adding a somber note to its otherwise good history.

Despite the challenges posed by clear water and limited overhead coverage, the creek’s numerous tributaries help maintain cool water temperatures, enhancing the fishing environment. 

Boat Ramps, Boat Launches, Marinas, and Public Access Points.

Accessing the pristine waters of Schoharie Creek is made possible through the Schoharie Creek Parking Fishing Access.

This fishing area offers a convenient and accessible point for anglers, providing parking facilities for those eager to explore the scenic waterways. 

Near Central Bridge Community Park and the peak of Terrace Mountain, the Schoharie Creek Parking Fishing Access is a gateway to the natural beauty that defines Schoharie County.

The historic Schoharie Bridge, also known as Fox Creek Bridge, which stands as a wooden covered bridge over Fox Creek makes as a good marker.

Located a short distance, 2½ miles southeast of the Schoharie Creek Parking Fishing Access, the bridge contributes to the cultural and historical richness of Schoharie County.

As anglers explore this region, they can appreciate not only the fishing opportunities but also the scenic and historical elements that make Schoharie Creek a unique destination for fisherman.